A business acquisition attorney takes a transaction from letter of intent to closing: structuring, diligence, the purchase agreement, consents and the post-closing adjustment. The work that determines the outcome happens before the definitive documents are drafted, not during.
Key takeaways
Structure is decided first because liability, consents and tax all follow from it.
The questions capable of ending a deal are cheap and belong at the start.
Statutory clocks run on agency time and set the floor for any closing date.
Some liabilities reach a buyer regardless of the agreement, and deserve disproportionate attention.
The post-closing adjustment is where agreed prices change, so its basis belongs in the LOI.
Most deals that fail do so after the price is agreed. The parties shake hands on a number, instruct lawyers, and the transaction then runs into a licence that cannot transfer, a landlord who will not consent, a tax clearance that takes longer than the closing date allows, or an earnings figure that does not survive examination.
None of those are legal problems in the ordinary sense. They are sequencing problems — questions asked in the wrong order, or asked once the answer could no longer change anything.
For a buyer or seller in Pleasant Hill or elsewhere in Contra Costa County, this page sets out what the work actually involves, in the order that works, and which parts of it matter most on a privately held business.
Definitive agreement
The binding purchase agreement that governs the transaction, as distinct from the letter of intent, setting out the consideration, representations, covenants, conditions to closing and the indemnity package.
Choose the structureAsset purchase, equity purchase or merger, decided on the liability, consent and tax consequences together.
Ask the deal-breakers firstTransferability, owner dependence, change of control clauses and customer concentration.
Start the clocksTax clearance, landlord consents and licence applications all run on someone else’s timetable.
Negotiate the agreementRepresentations, indemnity, escrow and the conditions to closing, informed by what diligence found.
Work the adjustmentThe working capital true-up after closing is where the agreed price actually settles.
The sequence of a privately held business acquisition.
From risk to resolution
Problem
Lawyers instructed after the deal is agreed
Price, structure and a closing date are settled before anyone examines the contracts, the licences or the tax position. The structural questions surface weeks later, when the financing is committed and the timetable cannot move.
Solution
Settle structure and the hard questions first
The structure is chosen on its liability, consent and tax consequences together. The questions that could end the deal are asked in the first week. Statutory clocks start immediately rather than when someone remembers them.
Resolution
A closing that happens on schedule
Consents are in hand, clearances have been requested in time, and the agreement reflects what diligence found. The surprises arrived while the price was still open, which is the only point at which a surprise is useful.
Structure comes first because everything follows from it
The choice between an asset purchase, an equity purchase and a merger is usually made early and casually, and it determines the shape of everything that follows.
An asset purchase transfers identified assets and assumes only specified liabilities, leaving the selling entity in existence. It is generally favourable to a buyer on liability and on tax, and it requires the most consents, because contracts are being assigned rather than retained.
An equity purchase transfers the entity itself. Nothing inside it moves, so consents are needed far less often, and every liability travels whether or not diligence found it. The protection comes from the representations and the indemnity rather than from a schedule.
A merger is the third route and its consequences are set by statute rather than negotiated. The liabilities of the constituent corporations pass to the survivor by operation of law, which removes the assumption question and replaces it with complete exposure, known in advance.
The honest approach is to run enough diligence to understand the liability history and the consent requirements before the structure is committed, then let the facts choose. The common approach — fixing the structure in the letter of intent and discovering the consequences afterwards — is where most structural regret originates.
The liabilities that reach a buyer anyway
A purchase agreement allocates risk between the people who sign it. Categories arising by operation of law are unaffected by that allocation, and they deserve attention out of proportion to their apparent size.
The baseline in California is that a corporation purchasing the principal assets of another does not assume the seller’s liabilities. The four traditional exceptions appear in Ray v. Alad Corp. (1977) 19 Cal.3d 22 at page 28: express or implied agreement to assume them; a transaction amounting in effect to a consolidation or merger; a buyer that is a mere continuation of the seller; and a transfer made fraudulently to escape liability for debts. At page 34 the court adopted a fifth, the product line exception, under which a buyer continuing to manufacture the same product line assumes strict tort liability for defects in units made before the acquisition.
The continuity exceptions are triggered by exactly the decisions that make an acquisition succeed — keeping the staff, the premises, the customers and the name — so the realistic response is to quantify the exposure rather than attempt to structure around it.
Where the seller is under financial pressure, a second body of law applies to the transaction itself. Civil Code section 3439.04 makes a transfer voidable as to a creditor where the debtor made it with actual intent to hinder, delay or defraud any creditor, or where the debtor did not receive reasonably equivalent value and either was engaged in a business for which its remaining assets were unreasonably small, or should have believed it would incur debts beyond its ability to pay. Subdivision (b) lists eleven factors, and subdivision (c) puts the burden on the creditor by a preponderance of the evidence. A buyer acquiring at an advantageous price from a struggling seller should be able to demonstrate why the price was reasonable.
Quantify rather than list
The useful output of this part of diligence is numbers rather than categories. Known creditors, open matters, accrued employment obligations and claims history are all measurable before closing.
An exposure with a figure attached can be priced, indemnified or escrowed. One described only as a risk tends to be answered with a representation, which is a promise rather than a remedy.
The clocks that set the closing date
Several steps in a business acquisition are not investigations at all. They are requests to third parties working to their own timetables, and no amount of agreement between buyer and seller compresses them.
The sales and use tax clearance is the clearest. Revenue and Taxation Code section 6812 gives the agency 60 days to issue the certificate or mail notice of the amount payable as a condition of issuing it, running from the latest of its receipt of the written request, the date of sale, or the date the former owner’s records are made available for audit. If the agency misses that window the purchaser is released from further withholding obligation. A purchaser who should have withheld and did not becomes personally liable for the amount to the extent of the purchase price valued in money, enforceable for three years after the agency is notified of the purchase.
The clock does not start until the request is made and the records are available, which means a late request simply moves the problem rather than solving it.
Landlord consent to assignment of a lease is the second, and it frequently takes longer than either party expects because the landlord has no incentive to hurry and often uses the opportunity to reopen terms. Licence and permit applications are the third, and where a licence is not transferable the buyer’s own application timetable becomes the deal timetable.
The practical rule is to identify every one of these in the first week and let the longest determine the closing date, rather than agreeing a date and then discovering it cannot be met.
The adjustment, and where the price actually settles
A price agreed in a letter of intent is rarely the amount that changes hands, and the mechanism that moves it is the post-closing adjustment.
Most privately held deals are agreed on a cash-free, debt-free basis with a normalised working capital target. The buyer is paying for a business delivered with enough working capital to operate normally, and the adjustment settles the difference between the target and what was actually delivered at closing.
Three things make this contentious. The target itself, which should be derived from historical averages over a period long enough to cover seasonality rather than picked. The definition of working capital, including which items are in and out, which matters more than the target figure. And the accounting policies applied, where a difference in how a reserve is calculated can move the number materially.
The dispute mechanism is the fourth element and is worth drafting properly. An independent accountant appointed under a stated process, with a defined scope limited to the items actually in dispute and a timetable, resolves most adjustments without litigation. The scope limitation matters: without it, an adjustment dispute can expand into a re-examination of the whole balance sheet.
All of this belongs in the letter of intent rather than the definitive agreement. A buyer and seller who agree a price without agreeing the basis on which it was calculated have not yet agreed a price.
Clark Meyers PC acts for buyers and sellers of privately held businesses in Contra Costa County from the firm’s Concord office at 1401 Willow Pass Road. The firm has no Pleasant Hill office; Pleasant Hill clients are served from Concord. Conor Meyers is licensed in California, Attorney License #157601, and has served as a chief executive and general counsel in operating businesses.
Buying or selling a Pleasant Hill business? The structure and the clocks should be settled before the closing date is.
The work covers structuring the transaction, running legal diligence, negotiating the purchase agreement and indemnity package, obtaining consents, and handling the post-closing adjustment that settles the final price.
Why does structure need to be decided first?
Liability exposure, the number of third-party consents required, and the tax position of both parties all follow from whether the deal is an asset purchase, an equity purchase or a merger. Changing it later is rarely practical.
Which questions should be asked first in diligence?
The ones capable of ending the transaction, because they are cheap and fast: whether licences transfer, whether the business depends on a departing owner, what key contracts say about change of control, and revenue concentration.
Which liabilities reach a buyer despite the agreement?
Those arising by operation of law: the four traditional successor exceptions from Ray v. Alad Corp., California’s product line exception, statutory tax withholding, and employment obligations attached to a continuing workforce.
How long does a tax clearance take?
The agency has 60 days to issue the certificate or mail notice of the amount payable, running from the latest of its receipt of the request, the date of sale, or the date the seller’s records are made available for audit.
What happens if a buyer does not withhold?
A purchaser who should have withheld from the purchase price becomes personally liable for that amount, to the extent of the purchase price valued in money, enforceable for three years after the agency is notified of the purchase.
What risk arises when buying from a distressed seller?
Civil Code section 3439.04 can make the transfer voidable as to a creditor where reasonably equivalent value was not received and the seller was left unable to pay debts as they came due, so the price should be demonstrably reasonable.
What is the working capital adjustment?
It settles the difference between a normalised working capital target and what was actually delivered at closing, on a price usually agreed on a cash-free, debt-free basis. It is where the agreed number actually moves.
When should the adjustment basis be agreed?
In the letter of intent rather than the definitive agreement. A buyer and seller who have agreed a price without agreeing the basis on which it was calculated have not yet agreed a price in any usable sense.
Business Acquisition Attorney in nearby Contra Costa County cities